Houston attorney stops ICE ordinance before council vote
Houston City Attorney Arturo Michel said Nov. 18 that a proposed ordinance limiting Houston police contacts with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) was unlawful as drafted. His legal review stopped the measure before a Houston City Council vote that day. It was not a court ruling or a Council vote.
The proposal was backed by Council Members Alejandra Salinas, Edward Pollard and Tiffany Thomas. It sought to put Mayor John Whitmireโs separate Executive Order 1-74 into city law and add information to Houston Police Department (HPD) quarterly reports. Michelโs decision did not invalidate the executive order, which took effect Nov. 6.
What the proposal would have changed
The ordinance would have converted the mayorโs operational policy into city law. Its additional reporting requirements would have asked HPD to state the basis for a jail booking, identify whether a person with a civil immigration warrant was a witness, victim or suspect, and provide a brief incident summary. Those additions were not adopted through this proposal because it did not reach a Council vote.
Executive Order 1-74 directs HPD not to contact ICE about someone who is not otherwise going to jail on new charges or other warrants. For someone meeting that threshold, it provides for contact when the person is going to jail on a jailable offense and has a positive National Crime Information Center (NCIC) hit for an ICE administrative warrant. The order also says immigration status alone is not a basis to contact ICE or prolong custody.
That distinction matters: Michelโs review stopped the proposed ordinance, not the separate executive order. The ordinance would have added reporting details and placed the policy in city law; the executive order itself directed HPD operations. The sponsors said codification would make the policy harder for a future mayor to change unilaterally.
Legal objections and possible reconsideration
Michel cited state-law concerns, including Senate Bill 4, and raised questions about the ordinanceโs effect on the mayorโs administrative authority. The sponsors said they had copied the executive-order language. Pollard argued that treating the ordinance differently from the order could weaken the cityโs position in its separate dispute with the state; that was his argument, not a court finding.
The Houston Chronicle reported that Whitmire and Michel said the issue could be revisited after incoming Attorney General Nathan Johnson took office in January. They did not identify a Council vote date, and the possible reconsideration was not a scheduled vote.
Sources
- Houston city attorney rejects council membersโ effort to codify Mayor Whitmireโs ICE order, Houston Chronicle
- City attorney rejects proposal to make Houston Mayor John Whitmireโs ICE policy law, ABC13 Houston
- Executive Order 1-74: An Executive Order Directing the Houston Police Department to Issue an Updated Circular Governing Contact with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, City of Houston
Ask Interactive NewsLook for updates to this storyFind out what has changed since this story was published.
Discover more from Interactive News
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.