D.C. Circuit keeps discharge protection in place for plaintiffs
The D.C. Circuit on Nov. 17, 2026, denied the federal governmentโs request to pause issuance of its mandate while the government seeks review by the U.S. Supreme Court. The court directed its clerk to issue the mandate forthwith, leaving in place a preliminary injunction that bars the Defense Department from expelling the currently serving plaintiffs in Talbott v. United States under the challenged policy.
The ruling resolves whether the appeals court would hold back its June decision during the Supreme Court process. It does not decide the constitutional challenge for good or create a nationwide protection for transgender service members.
The injunction covers retention, not joining the military
The challenged Defense Department policy disqualifies from military service people the department considers to express a โfalse gender identity.โ On June 1, the D.C. Circuit concluded that the policy likely violates the Constitutionโs equal-protection guarantee and affirmed preliminary relief for plaintiffs already serving.
The court drew a separate line for people seeking accessionโthe military term for joining. It vacated the injunction for plaintiffs seeking to enter the military. The protection in Talbott therefore bars expulsion of the specified currently serving plaintiffs; it does not require the department to accept applicants or extend the injunction to all transgender service members.
The November order does not list the covered plaintiffs by name or state a total. The Associated Press reported that plaintiffsโ attorneys said 27 service members are covered. That is the attorneysโ count as reported by AP, not a number supplied by the court.
The June ruling was preliminary: the appeals court found the plaintiffs likely to succeed on the equal-protection issue, rather than entering a final judgment that the policy is unconstitutional. The November order addresses only the governmentโs request to delay the mandate, leaving the ultimate constitutional question unresolved.
Supreme Court review is still pending
The government filed its petition asking the Supreme Court to review the case on Aug. 27, 2026. The Supreme Court docket shows that the petition was distributed for the Courtโs Dec. 4 conference. As of the docketโs Nov. 17 update, the justices had not decided whether to hear the appeal. Distribution for a conference is not a decision to take the case.
The sequence is June 1, when the D.C. Circuit ruled on the injunction; Aug. 27, when the government filed its Supreme Court petition; and Nov. 17, when the appeals court refused to delay its mandate. The Dec. 4 conference is the next date listed on the Supreme Court docket.
The Associated Press reported that the appeals court denied the stay request 2โ1. The November order states that Judge Justin Walker would have granted the governmentโs motion. In an attached statement explaining his vote, Judge Robert Wilkins said the government had not shown irreparable harm from retaining the currently serving plaintiffs and had not specified the national-security risks it asserted. Wilkinsโs explanation is his statement, not a separate majority opinion.
Sources
- Order denying stay of mandate, Talbott v. United States, No. 25-5087, U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit
- Talbott v. United States, No. 25-5087, U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit
- Divided appeals court blocks Pentagon from expelling several transgender troops from US military, Associated Press
- Docket for United States v. Talbott, No. 26-272, U.S. Supreme Court
Ask Interactive NewsLook for updates to this storyFind out what has changed since this story was published.
Discover more from Interactive News
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.