Rock Hill Police Solve 2016 Homicide Case with New Forensic Evidence

Rock Hill Police Solve 2016 Homicide Case with New Forensic Evidence

Rock Hill, SC — January 30, 2026 — In a significant breakthrough, Rock Hill police have solved a nearly decade-old homicide case. The investigation into the death of Walter Faile, found in his Hutchinson Street apartment on July 7, 2016, remained unsolved for years. However, recent advancements in forensic technology allowed detectives to reexamine the original evidence, leading to the identification of a fingerprint and, ultimately, a suspect.

Details of the Case

Walter Faile, 77, was discovered with multiple blunt force injuries and stab wounds, prompting an extensive investigation. Despite initial efforts, the case went cold due to a lack of leads. The recent application of new forensic methods provided the breakthrough needed to move forward.

Arrest and Investigation

On January 27, 2026, Paul Ray Craig Jr., 51, was arrested in connection with Faile’s murder. Police emphasized that the success of the case was due to a combination of technological advancements, diligent detective work, and valuable community tips. Lt. Michael Chavis of the Rock Hill Police Department stated, “Technology in all of society has advanced, but also in crime solving, so we have to use that when we have the opportunities.”

Community Impact

This development brings closure to the Faile family and the Rock Hill community, highlighting the importance of technological advancements in solving cold cases. The police department continues to encourage residents to come forward with any information that could assist in ongoing investigations.

Sources

• New forensic evidence leads to arrest in 2016 Rock Hill homicide – WSOC TV
• Rock Hill cold case solved after almost 10 years – WBTV